This or That is Would You Rather’s faster, punchier cousin. No elaborate dilemma, no hypothetical scenario, just two options and an instant pick. That speed is exactly what makes it work as an icebreaker: nobody overthinks “cats or dogs,” and the quick answers add up into a surprisingly good sense of who someone actually is. Below are 150-plus fresh questions across six categories, food and drink, entertainment, lifestyle, travel and adventure, deeper personality picks, and pure random fun.
Already a fan of party-question games? This site also has a Would You Rather game built into the homepage playground, a Truth or Dare list in Clean and Bold editions, and a Never Have I Ever game with 1,000 prompts, all part of the same party-games corner of this site. Want an even bigger stash of pairs? Our 500+ This or That questions for every group list goes deep by audience and theme.
How to play This or That
- One person reads a question aloud: “This, or that?”
- Everyone answers immediately, first instinct, no long deliberation.
- Optional: ask why. The reasoning behind a pick is often more interesting than the pick itself.
- Rotate who asks the next question, or let one person run through the whole list.
There’s no wrong answer and no real strategy, which is exactly why it works with any group size, from two people on a first date to a whole room at a party.
Food and Drink
- Pizza or tacos?
- Coffee or tea?
- Sweet or salty?
- Breakfast for dinner or dinner for breakfast?
- Chocolate or vanilla?
- Homemade meals or eating out?
- Spicy food or mild food?
- Pancakes or waffles?
- Soup or salad?
- Fresh bread or fresh cookies?
- Ice cream or cake?
- Fast food or slow-cooked meals?
- Cooking at home or ordering delivery?
- Crunchy peanut butter or smooth?
- Fries or onion rings?
- Sushi or burgers?
- Sparkling water or still water?
- A big breakfast or skipping straight to lunch?
- Grilling outdoors or cooking indoors?
- Dessert first or dessert last?
- Cereal or toast?
- A five-star restaurant or a hole-in-the-wall spot?
- Cheese on everything or cheese in moderation?
- Leftovers the next day or fresh food every time?
- Baking or cooking?
Entertainment: Movies, Shows, and Music
- Movies or TV shows?
- Comedy or drama?
- Reading the book first or watching the movie first?
- A long binge session or one episode at a time?
- Live music or a recorded album?
- Musicals or straight plays?
- Horror movies or action movies?
- Streaming a new release or rewatching an old favorite?
- Podcasts or audiobooks?
- A plot twist you didn’t see coming or one you called from the start?
- Animated movies or live action?
- A show with one long story or one with standalone episodes?
- Vinyl records or digital streaming?
- Concerts or festivals?
- Documentaries or fiction?
- Reading reviews before watching something or going in completely blind?
- A slow-burn series or a fast-paced one?
- Subtitles on or subtitles off?
- A movie theater or a home setup?
- Following a franchise for years or a standalone story?
- Karaoke or just listening?
- A soundtrack you can hum or lyrics you can quote?
- A cliffhanger ending or full closure?
- Watching alone or watching with a group?
- A remake or the original?
Lifestyle and Everyday Preferences
- Morning person or night owl?
- Early to bed or up late?
- A tidy desk or organized chaos?
- Planning every detail or going with the flow?
- A quiet night in or a night out?
- Texting or calling?
- Handwritten notes or typed notes?
- A big to-do list or a short one?
- Working from home or working in an office?
- A hot shower or a cold one?
- Making the bed every morning or leaving it?
- A digital calendar or a paper planner?
- Silence while working or background noise?
- Saving money or spending on experiences?
- A structured routine or spontaneity?
- Reading physical books or e-books?
- A single big vacation a year or several small trips?
- Minimalism or collecting things you love?
- Working out in the morning or the evening?
- A window seat or an aisle seat?
- Staying in touch by text or in person?
- A clean inbox or letting it pile up?
- Cooking a new recipe or sticking to your usual go-tos?
- Multitasking or one task at a time?
- A long shower or a quick one?
Travel and Adventure
- Mountains or beaches?
- City trips or countryside getaways?
- Road trips or flights?
- A packed itinerary or a loose plan?
- Camping or hotels?
- Backpacking or all-inclusive resorts?
- A new destination every time or returning to a favorite spot?
- Hiking or lounging?
- Solo travel or traveling with others?
- Winter destinations or summer destinations?
- A guided tour or exploring on your own?
- Street food while traveling or sit-down restaurants?
- Adventure sports or a relaxing getaway?
- A window view or an aisle for stretching room?
- Packing light or bringing everything just in case?
- Public transit in a new city or renting a car?
- Sunrise views or sunset views?
- A staycation or traveling somewhere new?
- National parks or big cities?
- Traveling by train or by plane?
- A spontaneous trip or one planned months ahead?
- Island hopping or one long stay in one place?
- Local markets or shopping malls?
- A trip focused on food or a trip focused on sights?
- Traveling in a group tour or completely independently?
Deeper Personality Picks
- Being early or being fashionably late?
- Speaking your mind or keeping the peace?
- A close circle of friends or a wide social network?
- Leading a group or supporting from the side?
- Learning from mistakes the hard way or avoiding risk altogether?
- A career you love with average pay or a job you tolerate with great pay?
- Being known for your work or being known for your personality?
- Giving advice or receiving it?
- Big life changes all at once or gradual change over time?
- Being right or being liked?
- Comfort zones or constant new challenges?
- Deep conversations or light banter?
- Being the funny one or the reliable one?
- Following your gut or following the data?
- A predictable life or an unpredictable one?
- Apologizing first or waiting for the other person to?
- Ambition or contentment?
- Being remembered for one big thing or many small things?
- Confidence or humility, if you had to lean harder into one?
- Taking initiative or waiting to be asked?
- Trusting easily or staying guarded at first?
- A structured career path or figuring it out as you go?
- Being the planner in a group or the one who goes along with it?
- Facing conflict head-on or letting things cool off first?
- Optimism or realism?
Random and Fun
- Superpowers or time travel?
- A pet dog or a pet cat?
- Summer or winter?
- Texting in full sentences or abbreviations?
- A phone call from an unknown number or a text from an unknown number?
- Board games or video games?
- A messy car or a clean one?
- Waking up to an alarm or waking up naturally?
- A quiet library or a bustling coffee shop for getting things done?
- Rainy days or sunny days?
- A themed party or a casual hangout?
- Karaoke night or trivia night?
- Puzzle games or strategy games?
- A road trip playlist or the radio?
- New shoes or an old, broken-in favorite pair?
- A window with a view or blackout curtains for sleep?
- Handwriting or typing?
- A big group photo or a candid one?
- Fireworks or a bonfire?
- A themed costume party or a regular get-together?
- Old-school flip phones or smartphones, if you had to relive one era?
- A treasure hunt or a straightforward gift?
- Star gazing or people watching?
- A surprise party or a planned celebration?
- Random small talk or comfortable silence?
Where to take this next
That’s 150-plus questions across six categories, more than enough for a full game night without repeating a single one. If you want more party-game energy, this site’s other games and lists work well together: our Truth or Dare list in Clean and Bold editions, our 200-plus Would You Rather questions, and our Never Have I Ever game all live in the same corner of this site, so a full game night can cycle through all four without ever running out of material. Need a spoken palate cleanser between rounds? Our hard tongue twisters list mixes classics with original phrases nobody else has heard. Still hungry for more pairs? Open the 500+ This or That mega list next. Just the two of you and no patience for a complicated setup? Our best two-player games when you’re both bored hub picks the quiet, shared-phone options that actually fit.

Discussion
Leave a comment
Thoughtful notes welcome. No links, no promo pitches. Your comment is emailed to us for review. Nothing goes live automatically.